Today's News: Chief Justice Pushes Back as Trump Calls for Judge’s Impeachment

Trump claims the judge's decision undermines his authority. Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. issued a statement rejecting the idea that impeachment should be a response to judicial decisions.

Photo: Julia Demaree Nikhinson/AP

Overview

• Date: March 18, 2025

• Topic: Trump Calls for Judge’s Impeachment Over Deportation Ruling, Chief Justice Pushes Back

• Summary: President Donald Trump called for the impeachment of U.S. District Judge James Boasberg after the judge blocked the administration’s deportation of Venezuelan migrants under the Alien Enemies Act. Trump and his allies claim the judge's decision undermines his authority to address illegal immigration. Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. issued a rare public statement rejecting the idea that impeachment should be used as a response to judicial decisions, emphasizing that appellate review is the appropriate legal mechanism. Republican lawmakers, including Representative Brandon Gill, introduced articles of impeachment against Boasberg. The legal battle over the deportations and the role of the judiciary in checking executive power has escalated tensions between the White House and the courts.

Sources

• The New York Times – Trump Administration Live Updates: Chief Justice Rebukes Calls for Judge’s Impeachment After Trump Remark

• CNN – Chief Justice Roberts Rebukes Trump and GOP Rhetoric About Impeaching Judges

• NBC News – Chief Justice Pushes Back Against Calls to Impeach Judges Who Rule Against Trump

• Fox News – Trump Calls for Judge in Deportation Legal Battle to Be Impeached

• The Washington Post – Chief Justice Rejects Calls by Trump and Allies to Impeach Judges

• The Wall Street Journal – Chief Justice Roberts Criticizes Trump’s Call to Impeach Judges

Key Points

• Trump’s Impeachment Demand: Trump called for the impeachment of Judge Boasberg after he temporarily blocked the administration’s deportation of alleged Venezuelan gang members.

• Chief Justice Roberts’ Response: Roberts rejected the idea that impeachment is an appropriate response to a judicial ruling and emphasized the role of appellate review.

• Republican Support for Impeachment: Representative Brandon Gill introduced articles of impeachment against Boasberg, citing “high crimes and misdemeanors” in his rulings.

• Broader GOP Criticism: Conservative figures, including Elon Musk and other Republican lawmakers, have been advocating for judicial impeachments following multiple rulings against Trump’s policies.

• Legal Battle Over Deportations: Trump invoked the Alien Enemies Act to justify the deportations, arguing that the migrants were part of Tren de Aragua, a Venezuelan gang. Judge Boasberg blocked the deportations, citing due process concerns.

• Escalating Executive vs. Judicial Conflict: The administration has suggested that the judiciary lacks authority to question the president’s immigration enforcement decisions, heightening concerns about a constitutional crisis.

Unique Highlights

• The New York Times: Provided historical context on Chief Justice Roberts’ previous rebukes of political figures, including Trump in 2018 and Chuck Schumer in 2020, for criticizing the judiciary.

• CNN: Highlighted Roberts’ complicated relationship with conservatives, noting that he previously ruled in favor of Trump on key issues such as presidential immunity but is now pushing back on the impeachment rhetoric.

• NBC News: Noted that judicial security concerns have risen due to threats against judges, with federal judges recently urging caution in public criticisms.

• Fox News: Emphasized Trump’s argument that the judge’s ruling was an obstacle to his immigration policies and his claim that he is simply fulfilling the will of the voters.

• The Washington Post: Discussed the broader implications of Trump’s attacks on the judiciary, noting rising threats against judges and Roberts’ ongoing defense of judicial independence.

• The Wall Street Journal: Explained that judicial impeachments are historically rare and discussed how Trump's impeachment push differs from past political efforts to remove judges.

Contrasting Details

• Tone on Roberts’ Response:

  • The New York Times, CNN, NBC News, The Washington Post, and The Wall Street Journal framed Roberts’ statement as a firm defense of judicial independence.

  • Fox News downplayed Roberts’ rebuke, emphasizing Trump’s claim that impeachment is necessary to combat “crooked judges.”

• Legal Perspective on Deportations:

  • The New York Times, CNN, and The Washington Post detailed the constitutional and legal arguments against using the Alien Enemies Act for deportations, emphasizing that the law was intended for wartime use.

  • Fox News focused on the administration’s justification, presenting the deportations as a necessary measure to combat criminal threats.

• Likelihood of Impeachment:

  • The New York Times, The Washington Post, and The Wall Street Journal noted that judicial impeachment is historically rare and unlikely to succeed due to the two-thirds Senate vote requirement.

  • Fox News and NBC News gave more weight to the growing support among House Republicans for impeachment proceedings.

---

The Newsie Project is an experiment using AI tools to survey contemporary reporting. It attempts to summarize, compare, and contrast the reporting of the major US online news sources.

This is an evolving project. Tools, approaches, and output formats will change over time. The Newsie Project does not attempt to provide a definitive capsule of any news story. While the incidence of errors in these summaries is low, and I attempt to spot-check details, AI tools can hallucinate. Please click through and read the articles for details (some may be paywalled).