Today's News: IRS Agrees to Share Tax Data With ICE, Acting Commissioner Resigns
The move marks a significant shift in agency policy, which triggered the resignations of Acting Commissioner Melanie Krause and other top IRS officials.
Photo: AP
Overview
Date: April 8, 2025
Topic: IRS Agreement to Share Tax Data With ICE Sparks Leadership Exodus and Legal Controversy
Summary: The Internal Revenue Service has signed a controversial agreement with Immigration and Customs Enforcement to share taxpayer data to assist with deportation efforts targeting undocumented immigrants. The move marks a significant shift in longstanding agency policy and has triggered the resignation of Acting Commissioner Melanie Krause and other top IRS officials. The Trump administration defends the agreement as a lawful use of tax data for criminal investigations, but critics argue it violates taxpayer privacy and undermines public trust. Advocacy groups have launched legal challenges, warning the policy could deter tax compliance and reduce federal revenue from undocumented workers.
Sources
The New York Times – Trump Administration Live Updates: I.R.S. Chief Said to Resign After Data-Sharing Deal With ICE
CNN – Acting IRS commissioner resigning after agency reaches data-sharing deal with immigration authorities
NBC News – IRS to share info with ICE about some undocumented immigrant taxpayers
The Washington Post – IRS chief to quit over deal to share data with immigration authorities
Wall Street Journal – Acting IRS Chief to Depart Amid Agency Tumult
Fox News – IRS and DHS reach historic deal to aid in pursuit of illegal immigrants subject to deportation
Key Points
The IRS and ICE finalized an agreement allowing the sharing of tax data to locate and deport undocumented immigrants with final removal orders.
The agreement relies on a criminal investigation exception to privacy laws governing tax data.
Acting IRS Commissioner Melanie Krause and several top officials resigned in protest, citing concerns over legality, lack of consultation, and agency direction.
The policy change marks a break from longstanding IRS norms that prioritized confidentiality for undocumented taxpayers to encourage tax compliance.
Legal experts and immigrant advocates fear the agreement will deter undocumented immigrants from filing taxes, risking up to $313 billion in lost federal revenue over 10 years.
Unique Highlights
The New York Times detailed internal dissent and resignation plans across senior IRS leadership, naming several officials departing alongside Krause.
CNN reported Krause was unaware of the final version of the agreement, learning its details through the press.
NBC News emphasized redactions in the court filing and DHS’s justification of information-sharing to identify public threats and scrub voter rolls.
The Washington Post noted pressure from the DOGE Service and that previous IRS heads left due to interference in agency operations.
The Wall Street Journal highlighted broader efforts by the Trump administration to shrink the IRS, including layoffs and IT modernization pauses.
Fox News framed the policy as a focused tool for deporting criminal aliens and underscored the MOU’s legal grounding and procedural safeguards.
Contrasting Details
Fox News characterized the agreement as narrowly focused on criminal deportation targets and consistent with congressional authority, while The New York Times, NBC News, and The Washington Post framed it as an overreach and departure from precedent.
NBC News and The Washington Post cited fears of widespread deterrence from tax filing among immigrants, whereas Fox News emphasized public safety and enforcement efficiency.
CNN portrayed Krause’s resignation as driven by being bypassed and blindsided, while Fox News did not mention internal dissent or resignations.
Wall Street Journal and The Washington Post emphasized legal risks and potential privacy violations, while Fox News stressed the policy’s alignment with national security priorities.
The Newsie Project is an experiment using AI tools to survey contemporary reporting. It attempts to summarize, compare, and contrast the reporting of the major US online news sources.
This is an evolving project. Tools, approaches, and output formats will change over time. The Newsie Project does not attempt to provide a definitive capsule of any news story. While the incidence of errors in these summaries is low, and I attempt to spot-check details, AI tools can hallucinate. Please click through and read the articles for details (some may be paywalled).